Review: Joe Cinque’s Consolation

October 12, 2016

Review, Theatrical, This Week 3 Comments

" unconventional mystery..."

Review: Joe Cinque’s Consolation

Travis Johnson
Year: 2016
Rating: M
Director: Sotiris Dounoukos

Maggie Naouri, Jerome Meyer, Gia Carides, Josh McConville, Sacha Joseph

Distributor: Titan View
Released: October 13
Running Time: 102 minutes
Worth: $14.00

FilmInk rates movies out of $20 — the score indicates the amount we believe a ticket to the movie to be worth

“…an unconventional mystery…”

Based on Helen Garner’s non-fiction book of the same title, Joe Cinque’s Consolation tells the story of the final days of the titular murder victim (Jerome Meyer), who died after his girlfriend, Anu Singh (Maggie Naouri) administered a fatal heroin overdose to him on October 26, 1997. Whereas Garner’s book concerned itself with Singh’s subsequent trial, writer and director Sotiris Dounoukos puts the spotlight on the doomed couple and, more intriguingly their social circle, and that’s where things become interesting.

What fascinates about the case is not that Cinque’s murder occurred, but that it was able to occur at all. Engineer Cinque and law student Singh were at the centre of a tangled social network of friends, colleagues and fellow students who all bore witness in some way or another as Singh, mentally unwell and given to histrionic fantasies of persecution and illness, begins to dream of, then actively plot, Cinque’s death. The film spends a lot of time with Singh, who initially posits to her friend and co-conspirator, Madhavi Rao (Sacha Joseph), that this will be a suicide pact. We see her plan Cinque’s death, acquiring Rohypnol and heroin to do the deed, and even going so far as to host a farewell dinner party – two, in fact; Singh’s first attempt fails, and the whole macabre event is staged again.

Naouri impresses as the erratic, obsessive Singh and Meyer is likable and relatable as her lover/victim, who struggles to help with her problems while unaware of her intentions. Australian screen stalwarts Gia Carides and Tony Nikolakopoulos likewise impress as Cinque’s parents. Unfortunately, the film is let down by a few flat performances in the surrounding ensemble, which is a pity; while the facts of Cinque’s death and Singh’s role in it are uncontestable, the film raises interesting questions about the culpability of their friends and what they could have done to prevent the tragedy.

Dounoukos conducts the proceedings with a detached, dispassionate eye, letting us observe the unfolding events without putting us in them. It lends the film a nightmarish quality, as we watch all the elements of Cinque’s death come together but are unable to intervene, separated from the scenario by the film’s cool tone. We’re spectators, like the rest of the Cinque/Singh circle, although our inaction is enforced.

The film stops short of giving concrete answers to the many questions it raises; indeed, it omits almost all of the events subsequent to the murder, leaving us only with the death itself. It’s an unconventional mystery, not so much asking whodunnit as why and how. Ultimately, Joe Cinque’s Consolation is a tragedy  and clearly a preventable one; the knowledge that justice was eventually served makes it no easier to bear witness to.



  1. Gavin

    Justice was served? Ha! Anu Singh was never properly held to account for this sickening crime thanks to a pathetic ACT judicial system …

  2. Julie

    “…the knowledge that justice was eventually served…” ha!. Having seen the movie yesterday, I’m of the view that justice clearly was not served. Singh’s friend, Rao robotically was an accessory to the crime for one. As I’ve yet to read the book,I can only surmise that a lack of evidence helped ensure she didn’t receive a jail sentence.. That Singh’s jail sentence was watered down from 10 to 4 years feels for reasons of ” diminished responsibility” or mental incapacity seemed all too generous to the killer.
    For me, this quietly powerful Aussie film- along with ” The Daughter ” is one of the the year’s best and certainly an accomplished debut.

Leave a Comment