by Stephen Vagg
In the early days of Australian television, you were as likely to see a locally-made drama based on French source material as an Australian one. This was because the bulk of that drama was produced by the ABC who had a brief to make “high culture” – and in the late 1950s and early 1960s that effectively meant Britain and Europe, rather than Australia (American material was generally distrusted at the ABC too but, unlike Australian drama, there was plenty to sample on the commercial stations). This attitude wasn’t restricted to television, but also prevalent in (some of) our arti-er theatres and on ABC radio.
So, in addition to adaptations of work by the usual suspects (Shakespeare, Shaw, Ibsen, Chekhov), the ABC filmed local versions of writers such as Jean Anouilh (very popular at the ABC), Andre Gide, Jean Sarment, Jean-Paul Sartre, Sacha Guitry, Moliere and Jean Cocteau.
Martine, shot at the ABC’s Melbourne studios in 1961, was based on a 1922 French play by Jean-Jacques Bernard, which had been translated into an English version by John Leslie Frith in 1929. No one much talks about this play today – it was never turned into a famous film, for instance, and Bernard never enjoyed the reputation in English-speaking countries of, say, Anouilh, Moliere or Cocteau – but for a time, Martine had quite a vogue: it played on the West End, was adapted a bunch of times for British radio and TV as well as for ABC radio, and was popular in amateur theatres in Britain and Australia.
The story is set in a French village in the 1890s, and concerns a lower-class girl, Martine (Annette Andre). She meets Jacques (Frederick Parslow), a dashing writer from the city who has come to stay with his grandmother (Barbara Brandon). He flirts with Martine for a day, and she takes it far too seriously, not realising granny wants Jacques to marry Jeanne (Joan Harris). Matters are complicated by a peasant, Alfred (Graham Hughes), who desires Martine.
I haven’t read the original play, but I can see the effect Bernard was going for: a wistful rural romance between two people of different classes that’s going to end unhappily for the peasantry, along the lines of the Max Ophuls film Letter from an Unknown Woman (1948) or John Galsworthy’s short story The Apple Tree (which was filmed in 1988 as A Summer Story). I’m guessing the reason it was so popular back in the day, is it involved a simple story with only a few roles, three of them meaty ones for female actors.
I recently watched the 1961 Australian version. I really enjoyed the sets and costumes and the performance of Annette Andre in the title role – she’s lovely, and genuinely heartbreaking. Andre didn’t always get roles worthy of her talent (like a lot of attractive younger actresses, she was often stuck playing “the girl” or “the daughter”), but here, she has something to get her teeth into and really rises to the occasion. The way Martine winds up treated by Jeanne and Jacques is actually quite horrible, and while the play is generally pitched as a melancholy romance, you could also see it working as a thriller about manipulative rich sociopaths.
Frederick Parslow, a hugely experienced and skilled actor, seems uneasily cast as Jacques, not quite attractive enough for Annette Andre to be so devoted. Maybe that’s shallow on my part, and I don’t want to upset any Frederick Parslow fans who might stumble upon this, but the whole play depends on us buying that Martine becomes obsessed with this guy after one afternoon’s flirting, and the way it’s done here is not terribly convincing. Having said that, I recognise that Louis Jourdans don’t grow on trees.
I’ll nail my nationalistic colours to the mast and add that I wish the play had been adapted to be set in Australia (incidentally, the adaptation was by Wal Cherry, a big name in Australian theatre). There’s no reason why the story couldn’t have been relocated here – we have small towns, unrequited love, and class differences. It would have given the piece’s existence more justification from a cultural point of view.
I watched a copy of Martine with Annette Andre – who I interviewed last year – and asked for her thoughts. She said:
“I didn’t remember anything about it, except that I had very blonde hair!!! I was surprised at my performance, I thought it played well, but I lacked the experience then to find more subtlety, change of pace and emotional variation in my character. Unfortunately, the sound wasn’t controlled, and some voices penetrated above and beyond. But, it was interesting for me to see it so many years later. It could have been a much better production with sound control, and it seemed too that some of our performances lacked a sense of relationship to each other.”
Out of interest, other ABC adaptations of works by French writers for television include Holiday in Biarritz (1957), Symphonie Pastorale (1958), The Lark (1958), Dinner with the Family (1959), Crime Passionel (1959), Two Headed Eagle (1960), Traveller without Luggage (1961), Don’t Listen Ladies (1963), The Fighting Cock (1963), Tartuffe (1965), Topaze (1966), and Point of Departure (1966).
The author would like to thank Annette Andre for her assistance with this article, even if she was overly self-deprecating about her own abilities.
For more articles like this, read:
60 Australian TV Plays of the 1950s & ‘60s
Annette Andre: My Brilliant Early Australian Career
Forgotten Australian TV Plays – The Slaughter of St Teresa’s Day
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: A Tongue of Silver
The Flawed Landmark: Burst of Summer
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Grey Nurse Said Nothing
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: You Can’t Win ‘Em All
Forgotten Australian TV plays: Marriage Lines
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Merchant of Venice
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Seagulls Over Sorrento
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Noeline Brown
Ten Female Drama Writers from the First Decade of Australian TV | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV plays: Romeo and Juliet | FilmInk
Sean Scully: From Disney to Australian TV Plays | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Long Sunset | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Reflections in Dark Glasses
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Case of Private Hamp | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Hot Potato Boys | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Life and Death of Richard II
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Harlequinade | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Outpost | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Rape of the Belt | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Murder Story | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Big Killing | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Antarctic Four
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Tape Recorder | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Man Who Saw It | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Scent of Fear
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Big Client | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Recruiting Officer | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Done Away With | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Split Level | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: She’ll Be Right | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV plays: Reunion Day | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Cell
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Swagman | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Cobwebs in Concrete | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: A Stay at Home and Across the Bridge | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Shifting Heart | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV plays: Kain | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Rusty Bugles | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: A Season in Hell | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Corinth House | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Tower | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Sweet Sad Story of Elmo and Me | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Drover’s Wife | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Five episodes of Australian Playhouse | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: In the Absence of Mr Sugden | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV plays: The Astronauts | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Monkey Cage | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: The Quiet Season and Enough to Make a Pair of Sailor’s Trousers
Forgotten Australian TV Plays: Shadow on the Wall | FilmInk
Forgotten Australian TV plays: Salome | FilmInk